Opinions and Orders

Please note: These electronic orders may contain computer-generated errors or other deviations from the official printed versions. In case of discrepancies between the print and electronic versions of orders, the print version controls. In case of discrepancies between the print and electronic versions of orders and any later official version of them, the later version controls.






Superior Court Complex Commercial Litigation Division Civil Opinions and Orders 75 Opinions

Parties/Caption Date File Number Court Type Judicial Officer Description
AM Buyer, LLC vs Argosy Investment Partners IV, L.P. et al. 09/03/2024 N23C-11-167 PRW CCLD Superior Court Civil Wallace
J. 		Memorandum Opinion and Order. Defendants’ Motion for Summary Judgment - GRANTED in part, DENIED in part; Defendants’ Request for Fees and Costs - DENIED.
JanCo FS 2, LLC, et al. v. ISS Facility Services, Inc., et al. 08/30/2024 N23C-03-005 MAA CCLD Superior Court Civil Adams
J. 		Memorandum Opinion. ISS’s Motion for Summary Judgment - GRANTED in part, and DENIED in part. JanCo’s Motion for Summary Judgment - GRANTED in part, and DENIED in part.
DDS Striker Holdings, LLC, et al. v. Verisk Analytics, Inc., et al. 08/29/2024 N24C-02-130 VLM CCLD Superior Court Civil Medinilla
J. 		Letter Opinion. Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss - GRANTED as to Count II, and DENIED as to Counts III through V; Defendants’ Motion to Strike - GRANTED.
TAKRAF USA, Inc. v. FMC Technologies, Inc. 08/28/2024 N24C-01-090 VLM CCLD Superior Court Civil Medinilla
J. 		Memorandum Opinion. Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss Amended Complaint - DENIED.
Aearo Technologies, LLC, et al., v. ACE American Insurance Co., et al. 08/26/2024 N23C-06-255 CCLD Superior Court Civil Rennie
J. 		Order. Plaintiffs’ Rule 59(e) Motion for Reargument on the Court’s July 15, 2024 Memorandum Opinion and Order Ruling – DENIED.
Estate of Jane Oristano v. Avmont, LLC, et al. 08/20/2024 N23C-04-258 EMD CCLD Superior Court Civil Davis
J. 		Memorandum Opinion. Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss – DENIED.
IN RE: CVS Opioid Insurance Litigation 08/20/2024 N22C-02-045 PRW CCLD Superior Court Civil Wallace
J. 		Memorandum Opinion and Order. Insurer's Motion for Partial Summary Judgment - GRANTED. CVS's Motion for Partial Summary Judgment - DENIED.
C3. Ai, Inc. v. Cummins, Inc. 08/16/2024 N23C-11-106 EMD CCLD Superior Court Civil Davis
J. 		Opinion. Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss – DENIED.
Huntsman International LLC, et al. v. Dow Benelux N.V., et al. 08/13/2024 N17C-11-242 MAA CCLD Superior Court Civil Adams
J. 		Memorandum Opinion. Dow’s Motion to Strike Expert Report of Christopher Norek - GRANTED. Dow’s Motion to Strike Portions of Expert Report of Louis Dudney - DEFERRED.
Huntsman International LLC, et al. v. Dow Benelux N.V., et al. 08/13/2024 N17C-11-242 MAA CCLD Superior Court Civil Adams
J. 		Opinion. Dow’s Motion for Sanctions for Spoliation - GRANTED.
Pazos v. AdaptHealth, LLC 08/12/2024 N23C-02-164 PRW CCLD Superior Court Civil Wallace
J. 		Memorandum Opinion and Order. Respondent’s Motion to Dismiss - GRANTED. Petitioner’s Motion for Summary Judgment - DENIED
Conlon, et al. v. CGI Manufacturing Buyer, LLC, et al. 08/08/2024 N23C-11-151 EMD CCLD Superior Court Civil Davis
J. 		Opinion. Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss Count II – GRANTED.
Benchmark Investments v. Pacer Advisors 07/29/2024 N23C-03-171 MAA CCLD Superior Court Civil Adams
J. 		Memorandum Opinion. Plaintiff’s Motion for Partial Summary Judgment - DENIED. Defendant’s Motion for Partial Summary Judgment - GRANTED.
Zenith Energy Terminals Joliet Holdings LLC, et al. v. CenterPoint Properties Trust 07/29/2024 N19C-10-054 EMD CCLD Superior Court Civil Davis
J. 		Opinion. Decision After Trial.
Callaway, et al. v. Delaware Examining Board of Physical Therapists and Athletic Trainers 07/26/2024 N23C-05-196 SKR CCLD Superior Court Civil Rennie
J. 		Memorandum Opinion and Order. Plaintiffs’ Motion for Summary Judgment – GRANTED. Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment – DENIED.
Syngenta Crop Protection, LLC v. Travelers Casualty and Surety Company et al. 07/24/2024 N21C-05-143 SKR CCLD Superior Court Civil Rennie
J. 		Revised Order. Moving Insurers’ Second Motion to Enforce the Court’s February 2, 2023, Discovery Order – GRANTED IN PART. DENIED IN PART.
Aearo Technologies LLC, et al. v. ACE American Insurance Company et al. 07/16/2024 N23C-06-255 SKR CCLD Superior Court Civil Rennie
J. 		Memorandum Opinion and Order. Plaintiffs’ Motion for Partial Summary Judgment: DENIED. General Star’s Motion for Partial Summary Judgment: GRANTED IN PART and DENIED IN PART. Twin City’s Motion for Partial Summary Judgment: GRANTED.
Feenix Payment Systems, LLC, et al. v. Blum 07/16/2024 N21C-05-099 EMD CCLD Superior Court Civil Davis
J. 		Order. Defendant’s Motion to Reargue or Amend or Alter Judgment – DENIED.
Massandra Capital IV, LLC v. CEAI Aspen Place Manager, LLC, et al. 07/15/2024 N23C-10-136 EMD CCLD Superior Court Civil Davis
J. 		Opinion. Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss – GRANTED.
Pearce, et al., v. Neuehealth, Inc. (f/k/a Bright Health Group, Inc.) 07/15/2024 N23C-09-005 SKR CCLD Superior Court Civil Rennie
J. 		Memorandum Opinion and Order. Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss - GRANTED in part, DENIED in part; Defendant’s Motion to Strike – GRANTED.
Westlake Pipe & Fittings Corporation v. Geon Performance Solutions, LLC 07/12/2024 N23C-08-096 EMD CCLD Superior Court Civil Davis
J. 		Opinion. Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss – GRANTED.
LGM Holdings, LLC, et al. v. Schurder, et al. 07/10/2024 N23C-09-011 EMD CCLD Superior Court Civil Davis
J. 		Opinion. Defendants’ Motions to Dismiss – GRANTED.
Premium Choice Insurance Services v. Innovative Financial Group Holdings, LLC et al. 07/09/2024 N24C-01-006 PRW CCLD Superior Court Civil Wallace
J. 		Memorandum Opinion and Order. Defendants' Motion to Dismiss - GRANTED in part, DENIED in part.
Surf's Up Legacy Partners, LLC, et al. v. Virgin Fest, LLC et al. 07/02/2024 N19C-11-092 PRW CCLD Superior Court Civil Wallace
J. 		Order. Defendant's Motion for Reargument - DENIED.
Pinnacle IV, L.P. v. Cyberlabs AI Holdings Limited, et al. 07/01/2024 N23C-04-021 MAA CCLD Superior Court Civil Adams
J. 		Civil Memorandum Opinion. Plaintiff's Motion to Dismiss Counterclaims, Strike Affirmative Defenses and for Judgment on the Pleadings - GRANTED.

* C.=Chancellor or Commissioner C.J.=Chief Justice or Chief Judge J.=Justice or Judge M.=Magistrate in Chancery P.J.=President Judge R.J.=Resident Judge V.C.=Vice Chancellor