Opinions and Orders

Please note: These electronic orders may contain computer-generated errors or other deviations from the official printed versions. In case of discrepancies between the print and electronic versions of orders, the print version controls. In case of discrepancies between the print and electronic versions of orders and any later official version of them, the later version controls.






Superior Court Complex Commercial Litigation Division Civil Opinions and Orders 77 Opinions

Parties/Caption Date File Number Court Type Judicial Officer Description
ETC Northeast Pipeline, LLC v. Associated Electric & Gas et al. 12/01/2023 N21C-10-177 MMJ CCLD Superior Court Civil Johnston
J. 		Opinion. Plaintiff’s Motion for Reconsideration of the Court’s Dismissal of Counts II, III, and IV - DENIED.
Shakesby v. SNC International, et al. 11/27/2023 N22C-11-070 MAA CCLD Superior Court Civil Adams
J. 		Letter Opinion. Defendants' Motion to Dismiss - GRANTED in part; DENIED in part.
Everphone, Inc. v. Go Technology Management, LLC 11/17/2023 N23C-03-022 PRW CCLD Superior Court Civil Wallace
J. 		Letter Opinion and Order. Defendant's Motion to Dismiss - DENIED in part; GRANTED in part.
AYANA Consult EOOD v. Whitehat Education Technology, LLC 11/14/2023 N23C-07-217 PRW CCLD Superior Court Civil Wallace
J. 		Order. Defendant's Motion to Dismiss - DENIED; Plaintiff's Cross-Motion for Partial Judgment - DENIED.
NSI-MI Holdings, LLC v. AMETEK, Inc. 11/13/2023 N22C-08-489 PRW Superior Court Civil Wallace
J. 		Memorandum Opinion and Order. Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment - GRANTED in part; DENIED in part.
Triple-S Steel Holdings v. Crowe LLP 11/08/2023 N23C-03-225 PRW Superior Court Civil Wallace
J. 		Letter Opinion and Order. Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss - DENIED in part; GRANTED in part.
Bayer Cropscience LP v. Corteva Inc. 11/06/2023 N22C-07-168 SKR CCLD Superior Court Civil Rennie
J. 		Opinion. Plaintiffs’ Motion to Strike and/or Dismiss Defendants’ Defense and Counterclaim of Patent Invalidity - DENIED.
CoVenture – Burt Credit Opportunities GP, LLC v. Joshua William Coleman, et al. 11/01/2023 N22C-07-197 MMJ CCLD Superior Court Civil Johnston
J. 		Opinion. Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss Amended Complaint - Granted in Part, Denied in Part.
NewWave Telecom and Technologies, Inc., v. Ze Jiang, et al. 10/19/2023 N20C-09-215 MMJ CCLD Superior Court Civil Johnston
J. 		Opinion. Defendants Motion for Reargument - DENIED.
CVR Refining, LP, et al. v. XL Specialty Insurance Company, et al. 10/12/2023 N21C-01-260 EMD CCLD Superior Court Civil Davis
J. 		Opinion. Defendant's Motion for Protective Order – DENIED. Plaintiff's Motion for Entry of Partial Judgment – DENIED.
NewWave Telecom and Technologies, Inc. v. Ze Jiang 09/27/2023 N20C-09-215 MMJ CCLD Superior Court Civil Johnston
J. 		Post-Trial Opinion.
Genworth Financial, et al. v. AIG Specialty Insurance et al. 09/21/2023 N22C-05-057 EMD CCLD Superior Court Civil Davis
J. 		Opinion. Plaintiffs' Motion for Partial Summary Judgment - GRANTED in part, and DENIED, in part. Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgment - DENIED.
Mattel, Inc., et al. v. XL Insurance American, Inc. et al. 09/20/2023 N23C-01-042 MAA CCLD Superior Court Civil Adams
J. 		Order. ACE Property and Casualty Insurance Company's Certification of Interlocutory Appeal, Application for Entry of Partial Final Judgment and Stay of Action - REFUSED.
Tilton, et al v. Stila Styles, LLC 09/19/2023 N23C-02-088 CCLD Superior Court Civil Rennie
J. 		Letter Opinion. Defendant’s Partial Motion to Dismiss and Plaintiff’s Motion for Partial Judgment on the Pleadings – DENIED.
CVR Refining, LP, et al. v. XL Specialty Insurance Company, et al. 09/13/2023 N21C-01-260 EMD CCLD Superior Court Civil Davis
J. 		Memorandum Opinion. Defendants' Motion to Stay - DENIED.
Mortgage Connect Document Solutions, LLC v. Green Industrial Development Group, LLC 09/11/2023 N23C-01-178 MAA CCLD Superior Court Civil Adams
J. 		Memorandum Opinion. Defendant's Motion to Dismiss - DENIED.
Arkray America, Inc. v. Navigator Business Solutions. Inc., et al. 09/05/2023 N20C-12-012 MMJ CCLD Superior Court Civil Johnston
J. 		Order. Defendants Motion in Limine - GRANTED. Plaintiff's Motion in Limine - GRANTED.
ETC Northeast Pipeline, LLC v. Associated Electric & Gas et al. 09/05/2023 N21C-10-177 MMJ CCLD Superior Court Civil Johnston
J. 		Opinion. On Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss Bad Faith Extracontractual Claims in Plaintiff’s Amended Complaint (Counts II-V) - GRANTED.
Intermec IP Corp., et al. v. Transcore, LP, et al. 08/31/2023 N20C-03-254 PRW CCLD Superior Court Civil Wallace
J. 		Decision After Trial.
Nucor Coatings Corp. v. Precoat Metals Corp., et al. 08/31/2023 N22C-11-222 MAA CCLD Superior Court Civil Adams
J. 		Memorandum Opinion and Order. Defendants' Motion to Dismiss - DENIED.
Envolve Pharmacy Solutions, Inc., et al. v. Rite Aid Hdqtrs. Corp., et al. 08/30/2023 N19C-12-214 PRW CCLD Superior Court Civil Wallace
J. 		Memorandum Opinion and Order. Plaintiffs' Motion for Judgment Notwithstanding the Verdict or, Alternatively, a New Trial - DENIED. Defendants' Motion for Costs - GRANTED.
In re CVS Opioid Insurance Litigation 08/25/2023 N22C-02-045 PRW CCLD Superior Court Civil Wallace
J. 		Opinion and Order (Corrected). Insurers’ and Joining Insurers’ Motions for Partial Summary Judgment - GRANTED.
Bright Data, Inc., et al. v. Meta Platforms, Inc., et al. 08/18/2023 N23C-01-229 SKR CCLD Superior Court Civil Rennie
J. 		Memorandum Opinion and Order. Defendant’s Motion to Stay - GRANTED.
Fin Cap Inc., et al. v. PayNerd LLC, et al. 08/16/2023 N21C-12-118 MMJ CCLD Superior Court Civil Johnston
J. 		Opinion. Plaintiffs' and Third-Party Defendants' Motion to Dismiss - GRANTED IN PART AND DENIED IN PART. Third-Party Defendant's Motion to Dismiss and Joinder - DENIED.
National Union Fire Insurance Company of Pittsburgh, PA. v. FedEx Corp., et al. 08/16/2023 N22C-08-488 EMD CCLD Superior Court Civil Davis
J. 		Order. Plaintiff’s Application for Certification of Interlocutory Appeal - REFUSED.

* C.=Chancellor or Commissioner C.J.=Chief Justice or Chief Judge J.=Justice or Judge M.=Magistrate in Chancery P.J.=President Judge R.J.=Resident Judge V.C.=Vice Chancellor