Opinions and Orders

Please note: These electronic orders may contain computer-generated errors or other deviations from the official printed versions. In case of discrepancies between the print and electronic versions of orders, the print version controls. In case of discrepancies between the print and electronic versions of orders and any later official version of them, the later version controls.






Superior Court Complex Commercial Litigation Division Civil Opinions and Orders 59 Opinions

Parties/Caption Date File Number Court Type Judicial Officer Description
Aearo Technologies LLC, et al. v. ACE American Insurance Company et al. 07/16/2024 N23C-06-255 SKR CCLD Superior Court Civil Rennie
J. 		Memorandum Opinion and Order. Plaintiffs’ Motion for Partial Summary Judgment: DENIED. General Star’s Motion for Partial Summary Judgment: GRANTED IN PART and DENIED IN PART. Twin City’s Motion for Partial Summary Judgment: GRANTED.
Feenix Payment Systems, LLC, et al. v. Blum 07/16/2024 N21C-05-099 EMD CCLD Superior Court Civil Davis
J. 		Order. Defendant’s Motion to Reargue or Amend or Alter Judgment – DENIED.
Massandra Capital IV, LLC v. CEAI Aspen Place Manager, LLC, et al. 07/15/2024 N23C-10-136 EMD CCLD Superior Court Civil Davis
J. 		Opinion. Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss – GRANTED.
Pearce, et al., v. Neuehealth, Inc. (f/k/a Bright Health Group, Inc.) 07/15/2024 N23C-09-005 SKR CCLD Superior Court Civil Rennie
J. 		Memorandum Opinion and Order. Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss - GRANTED in part, DENIED in part; Defendant’s Motion to Strike – GRANTED.
Westlake Pipe & Fittings Corporation v. Geon Performance Solutions, LLC 07/12/2024 N23C-08-096 EMD CCLD Superior Court Civil Davis
J. 		Opinion. Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss – GRANTED.
LGM Holdings, LLC, et al. v. Schurder, et al. 07/10/2024 N23C-09-011 EMD CCLD Superior Court Civil Davis
J. 		Opinion. Defendants’ Motions to Dismiss – GRANTED.
Premium Choice Insurance Services v. Innovative Financial Group Holdings, LLC et al. 07/09/2024 N24C-01-006 PRW CCLD Superior Court Civil Wallace
J. 		Memorandum Opinion and Order. Defendants' Motion to Dismiss - GRANTED in part, DENIED in part.
Surf's Up Legacy Partners, LLC, et al. v. Virgin Fest, LLC et al. 07/02/2024 N19C-11-092 PRW CCLD Superior Court Civil Wallace
J. 		Order. Defendant's Motion for Reargument - DENIED.
Pinnacle IV, L.P. v. Cyberlabs AI Holdings Limited, et al. 07/01/2024 N23C-04-021 MAA CCLD Superior Court Civil Adams
J. 		Civil Memorandum Opinion. Plaintiff's Motion to Dismiss Counterclaims, Strike Affirmative Defenses and for Judgment on the Pleadings - GRANTED.
Channel PES Acquisition Co., LLC v. Heritage-Crystal Clean, Inc. 06/30/2024 N23C-08-206 MAA CCLD Superior Court Civil Adams
J. 		Memorandum Opinion. Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss - GRANTED in part, DENIED in part.
Hartree Natural Gas Storage, LLC v. Euclid Transactional, LLC, et. al 06/28/2024 N22C-05-081 PRW CCLD Superior Court Civil Wallace
J. 		Letter Decision and Order. Plaintiff's Motion to Compel - GRANTED in part, DENIED in part; Defendant's Motion to Bifurcate and Stay All Discovery - DENIED; Defendant's Motion for Leave to Serve Requests - GRANTED; Defendant's Motions to Compel - DENIED.
Active Day OH, Inc. et al. v. Wehr et al. 06/27/2024 N22C-08-064 SKR CCLD Superior Court Civil Rennie
J. 		Memorandum Opinion and Order. Defendants’ Motion for Summary Judgment – DENIED.
Matrix Parent, Inc., et al. v. Audax Management Company, LLC, et al. 06/27/2024 N23C-10-212 MAA CCLD Superior Court Civil Adams
J. 		Opinion. Defendants' Motion to Dismiss - GRANTED in part, DENIED in part.
The Cigna Group v. XL Specialty Insurance Company, et al. 06/27/2024 N23C-03-009 SKR CCLD Superior Court Civil Rennie
J. 		Memorandum Opinion and Order. Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel Discovery Directed at Defendant - GRANTED in part, DENIED in part.
Slingshot Technologies, LLC v. Acacia Research Corp., et al. 06/20/2024 N23C-11-166 EMD CCLD Superior Court Civil Davis
J. 		Opinion. Defendants’ Motion for Summary Judgment – DENIED.
DuPont de Nemours, Inc. et al. v. Hemlock Semiconductor Operations LLC 06/10/2024 N23C-10-261 PRW CCLD Superior Court Civil Wallace
J. 		Memorandum Opinion and Order. Plaintiffs' Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings - DENIED; Plaintiffs' Motion to Dismiss - DENIED in part, GRANTED in part.
Ford Motor Company v. Earthbound LLC. 06/05/2024 N23C-06-237 PRW CCLD Superior Court Civil Wallace
J. 		Memorandum Opinion and Order. Plaintiff's Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings - DENIED; Defendant's Cross-Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings - DENIED.
Talkdesk, Inc. v. DM Trans, LLC d/b/a Arrive Logistics 05/31/2024 N23C-08-005 MAA CCLD Superior Court Civil Adams
J. 		Memorandum Opinion. Plaintiff’s Motion to Dismiss - GRANTED in Part, and DENIED in Part
Ashland LLC, et al. v. Heyman, et al. 05/30/2024 N15C-10-176 EMD CCLD Superior Court Civil Davis
J. 		Memorandum Opinion. Plaintiffs’ Motion for Re-argument – DENIED.
Yangaroo Inc. v. Digital Media Services, Inc., et al. 05/30/2024 N23C-06-090 EMD CCLD Superior Court Civil Davis
J. 		Opinion. Defendants’ Motions to Dismiss – Granted in part, Denied in Part. Defendant SR Capital Advisors, LLC’s Motion to Dismiss – GRANTED.
Feenix Payment Systems, LLC, et al. v. Blum 05/29/2024 N21C-05-099 EMD CCLD Superior Court Civil Davis
J. 		Opinion. Decision After Trial.
Flexwage Solutions LLC v. Ceridian HCM Holding Inc., et al. 05/13/2024 N23C-04-086 EMD CCLD Superior Court Civil Davis
J. 		Opinion. Defendants’ Partial Motion to Dismiss – GRANTED.
BioMerieux, Inc. et al. v. Rhodes, et al. 05/09/2024 N23C-10-067 SKR CCLD Superior Court Civil Rennie
J. 		Memorandum Opinion and Order. Defendants’ Motion to Strike – GRANTED. Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss – GRANTED, in part, DENIED, in part.
Origis USA, LLC et al. v. Great American Insurance Company, et al. 05/09/2024 N23C-07-102 SKR CCLD Superior Court Civil Rennie
J. 		Memorandum Opinion and Order. Defendants’ Motions to Dismiss – GRANTED.
Outbox Systems, Inc. v. Trimble, Inc. 04/30/2024 N21C-11-123 PRW CCLD Superior Court Civil Wallace
J. 		Decision After Trial

* C.=Chancellor or Commissioner C.J.=Chief Justice or Chief Judge J.=Justice or Judge M.=Magistrate in Chancery P.J.=President Judge R.J.=Resident Judge V.C.=Vice Chancellor